When Assisted Reproduction Does Not Go as Planned

Assisted reproductive technology (ART), including in vitro fertilization (IVF), has helped countless individuals and families achieve their dreams of parenthood. But when something goes wrong, the legal and emotional consequences can be devastating.

A fertility clinic may transfer the wrong embryo, use incorrect sperm or eggs, lose or destroy frozen embryos, or make errors involving genetic testing or reproductive procedures. Disputes may also arise over surrogacy agreements, parental rights, embryo ownership, or the legal responsibilities of parties involved in assisted reproduction.

These cases present complicated questions involving reproductive rights, consent, contractual obligations, genetic relationships, legal parentage, and potential medical negligence.

Litigation Focused

Litigation Focused on Family Formation

At Tate Healey Webster, our attorneys focus on the complex intersection of assisted reproductive technology, adoption law, parental rights, and litigation. We represent individuals and families navigating disputes involving IVF, surrogacy, reproductive agreements, and other ART-related legal matters.

Our firm has been involved in high-profile ART litigation that has attracted national media attention, including coverage by The Wall Street Journal and New York Magazine.

We understand that these matters involve far more than legal disagreements. They involve deeply personal decisions, the creation of families, and, in many cases, the future of children.

IVF Errors, Fertility Clinic Disputes & Reproductive Negligence

Fertility patients place extraordinary trust in the physicians, laboratories, and medical professionals responsible for their reproductive care. When mistakes occur, the consequences may extend far beyond the medical procedure itself.

Errors involving embryos, sperm, eggs, genetic testing, and fertility treatments can raise significant legal questions involving informed consent, contractual rights, reproductive autonomy, and legal parentage.

Our attorneys assist clients in evaluating the legal implications of fertility clinic errors and related reproductive disputes, including the following:

Banner media

Wrong Embryo Implanted or Transferred During IVF

One of the most serious errors that can occur during IVF is the transfer or implantation of the wrong embryo.

An IVF clinic may mistakenly transfer an embryo belonging to another patient, implant an embryo created using the wrong genetic material, or transfer an embryo to the wrong intended recipient.

These mistakes can create extraordinary legal complications involving genetic parentage, legal parentage, custody, consent, and the rights of everyone involved.

If an IVF clinic transferred the wrong embryo, the resulting legal questions may include who is recognized as the child’s legal parent, what rights the genetic parents may have, and what remedies may be available.

Tate Healey Webster assists clients navigating the complex legal and parentage issues that arise from embryo mix-ups and incorrect embryo transfers.

Wrong Sperm or Egg Used During IVF

Fertility clinic errors involving sperm or eggs can fundamentally alter the genetic relationships that patients intended to create.

These mistakes may include using the wrong sperm donor, fertilizing an egg with another patient’s sperm, using the wrong donor egg, or otherwise using reproductive material without the required consent.

Such errors can raise significant questions involving informed consent, donor agreements, genetic parentage, legal parentage, and potential claims against fertility providers.

Our attorneys help clients understand the reproductive-law implications of these mistakes and evaluate available legal options.

Lost, Damaged, or Destroyed Embryos

Frozen embryos often represent years of medical treatment, financial investment, and emotional commitment.

When a fertility clinic loses, damages, or destroys embryos, the consequences can be devastating.

Embryo loss or destruction may result from:

  • Cryogenic storage tank failures
  • Equipment malfunctions or power failures
  • Laboratory handling errors
  • Improper freezing or thawing procedures
  • Mislabeling or misidentification of embryos
  • Unauthorized disposal or destruction
  • Failure to follow established storage protocols

These circumstances may raise complex questions involving fertility clinic agreements, consent, reproductive rights, and potential legal remedies.

Our attorneys evaluate the reproductive-law and contractual issues arising from the loss or destruction of embryos and work with appropriate professionals when additional legal expertise is required.

IVF Genetic Testing and Embryo Screening Errors

Genetic testing is frequently used during fertility treatment to help patients make informed decisions about embryo selection and transfer.

Errors involving preimplantation genetic testing (PGT), embryo screening, laboratory identification, or the reporting of genetic results can have serious consequences.

Potential disputes may involve incorrect test results, misidentified embryos, inaccurate reporting, or the transfer of an embryo inconsistent with the patient’s informed consent.

These situations can raise complicated legal issues involving consent, contractual obligations, reproductive decision-making, and potential professional negligence.

Unauthorized Use, Transfer, or Disposal of Embryos and Reproductive Material

Disputes can arise when embryos, sperm, or eggs are used, transferred, donated, or destroyed without proper authorization.

Examples may include reproductive material being used contrary to written instructions, embryos transferred without the necessary consent, or disagreements over whether a clinic followed the parties’ reproductive agreements.

Our attorneys assist clients with the complex legal questions involving consent, reproductive agreements, and the rights of individuals whose reproductive material has been improperly handled.

IVF-Related Physical Injuries and Fertility Treatment Negligence

Fertility treatment may involve egg retrieval, hormone administration, embryo transfer, and other medical procedures.

When medical errors occur, patients may experience physical injuries or complications that warrant further legal investigation.

These matters may involve medical malpractice issues as well as separate questions concerning reproductive agreements, informed consent, and legal parentage.

Tate Healey Webster evaluates the reproductive-law implications of these disputes and, when appropriate, works alongside medical malpractice counsel to address related claims.

ART Litigation, Surrogacy Disputes & Parental Rights

Assisted reproductive technology can also create complex legal disputes even when no medical error has occurred.

Disagreements involving surrogacy agreements, embryo disposition, donor arrangements, and parental rights may require litigation to determine the legal rights and responsibilities of the parties.

Our attorneys have extensive experience navigating the intersection of Florida adoption law, assisted reproductive technology, and contested family litigation.

Banner media

Surrogacy Agreement Disputes

Gestational surrogacy arrangements involve important legal rights and responsibilities for intended parents, gestational carriers, and, in some circumstances, other parties.

Disputes may arise concerning the interpretation, validity, or enforcement of a surrogacy agreement, the parties’ obligations, or the establishment of legal parentage.

Our attorneys represent clients in complex surrogacy disputes, including matters involving interstate and international arrangements. If you are still planning your arrangement, learn more about gestational surrogacy agreements.

Contested Parentage and Parental Rights

Determining legal parentage following assisted reproduction can become particularly complicated when disputes arise between intended parents, genetic parents, gestational carriers, or other interested parties.

These cases may involve competing claims to parentage, questions concerning consent, recognition of parentage orders, and the interaction between Florida adoption law and assisted reproductive technology statutes.

Tate Healey Webster represents clients in contested parentage proceedings and other litigation involving the legal rights of parents and children.

Frozen Embryo Ownership, Custody, and Disposition Disputes

Disagreements concerning frozen embryos may arise following divorce, separation, changes in family circumstances, or disagreements between individuals who previously pursued fertility treatment together.

These disputes may involve whether embryos can be used, transferred, donated, stored, or destroyed and whether existing agreements govern those decisions.

Our attorneys assist clients in understanding their rights and obligations concerning embryo disposition and reproductive agreements.

Donor Egg, Sperm, and Embryo Agreement Disputes

Third-party reproduction involving donated sperm, eggs, or embryos can raise significant legal issues concerning consent, contractual obligations, and parental rights.

Disputes may arise when parties disagree about the terms of donor agreements, the intended legal consequences of a donation, or the rights and responsibilities of donors and intended parents.

Our attorneys assist clients in resolving these complicated reproductive-law disputes.

LGBTQ+ Family Formation and Parentage Disputes

Assisted reproductive technology provides important family-building opportunities for same-sex couples and LGBTQ+ individuals.

However, legal disputes may arise involving parental recognition, surrogacy arrangements, donor agreements, or the establishment and protection of parental rights.

Our attorneys assist LGBTQ+ individuals and families with contested parentage matters and other legal disputes involving assisted reproduction. Learn more about LGBTQ+ adoption and family formation.

Interstate and International ART Litigation

Assisted reproductive arrangements increasingly involve parties located in different states or countries.

These matters can raise complicated jurisdictional questions, conflicting legal requirements, and disputes concerning the recognition or enforcement of parental rights and court orders.

Our firm represents clients in complex interstate and international ART matters involving reproductive agreements, parentage, and related legal disputes.

Enforcement and Challenges to Reproductive Agreements

Surrogacy contracts, donor agreements, embryo disposition agreements, and other reproductive contracts can become the subject of litigation when disagreements arise.

Our attorneys assist clients in interpreting, enforcing, and challenging reproductive agreements when disputes threaten the parties’ rights or intended family-building arrangements.

Why Choose Tate Healey Webster for IVF and ART Litigation?

A Practice Focused on Adoption and Assisted Reproductive Technology Law

Unlike firms that handle reproductive disputes as one part of a broad general practice, Tate Healey Webster focuses on adoption, assisted reproductive technology, and the legal issues surrounding family formation.

Our experience provides an understanding of the complex relationships between reproductive agreements, genetic connections, legal parentage, and the rights of children and families.

Experience in Complex, High-Profile Litigation

Our attorneys have handled contested proceedings involving complicated and evolving questions of reproductive law and parental rights.

Our firm’s involvement in significant ART litigation has attracted national and regional media attention, reflecting the importance and complexity of the legal issues involved.

Four Board-Certified Adoption Law Attorneys

Tate Healey Webster is home to four attorneys Board Certified in Adoption Law by The Florida Bar.

Our firm’s experience in adoption and parentage matters provides an important foundation for litigation involving assisted reproduction, particularly when questions concerning legal parentage and the rights of children arise.

Sophisticated Litigation Experience

ART disputes can involve multiple overlapping areas of law, including contract law, adoption law, family law, jurisdictional issues, and medical negligence.

Our attorneys understand the importance of developing litigation strategies that address these intersecting legal issues while protecting our clients’ interests.

Compassionate, Discreet Representation

Disputes involving infertility, embryos, genetic relationships, surrogacy, and parental rights can be extraordinarily personal.

We approach these matters with sensitivity, discretion, and an understanding of the emotional and legal challenges our clients face.

Background media
man and woman looking at paperwork

ART Litigation Experience That Has Attracted National Attention

Tate Healey Webster has been involved in complex assisted reproductive technology litigation that has attracted attention from prominent national and regional news organizations.

Our firm’s litigation experience has been featured or discussed in publications and news outlets including:

  • The Wall Street Journal
  • New York Magazine / The Cut
  • First Coast News
  • Florida Politics
  • Daily Caller News Foundation

These matters reflect the increasingly complex legal questions arising from assisted reproductive technology, reproductive agreements, and the determination of parental rights.

Contact us media
Contact us media

Speak With Us Today

Your Trusted Partner in the Adoption & Surrogacy Process

Frequently Asked Questions IVF Errors and ART Litigation in Florida

What happens if an IVF clinic implants the wrong embryo?

If a fertility clinic transfers or implants the wrong embryo, the situation may create complicated legal questions involving genetic parentage, legal parentage, consent, and the rights of the individuals involved. The available legal options depend on the circumstances, the applicable agreements, and state law. An attorney experienced in assisted reproductive technology law can help evaluate these issues.

Can I sue an IVF clinic for using the wrong embryo?

Depending on the circumstances, an incorrect embryo transfer may give rise to potential legal claims. These may involve medical negligence, breach of contract, informed consent, or other legal theories. The viability of any claim depends on the facts and applicable law. Separate legal proceedings may also be necessary to address questions of parentage or parental rights.

What if my fertility clinic used the wrong sperm or donor egg?

Using the wrong sperm or egg during IVF can raise significant legal questions involving informed consent, genetic relationships, reproductive agreements, and potential negligence. An attorney can help determine the legal implications and whether additional proceedings are necessary to address parentage or other rights.

Can I sue a fertility clinic for losing or destroying my embryos?

The loss or destruction of frozen embryos may give rise to potential legal claims depending on the circumstances, the clinic’s contractual obligations, and applicable law. Claims involving embryo destruction can present complicated legal questions concerning damages, consent, and reproductive rights.

What if my IVF clinic made a genetic testing mistake?

Errors involving embryo genetic testing or screening may raise questions concerning informed consent, laboratory procedures, contractual obligations, and potential professional negligence. The available remedies depend on the nature of the error and its consequences.

What should I do if I discover an IVF embryo mix-up?

If you believe an IVF clinic transferred the wrong embryo or used incorrect reproductive material, consider obtaining copies of your treatment records, laboratory reports, consent forms, and reproductive agreements. Preserve relevant communications and seek legal advice promptly. Avoid making decisions about genetic testing, disclosure, or parentage arrangements without understanding the potential legal implications.

Who is the legal parent if the wrong embryo was implanted?

Legal parentage following an embryo mix-up can involve complicated questions concerning genetics, gestation, consent, marital status, reproductive agreements, and applicable state law. Genetic parentage does not necessarily resolve legal parentage. These disputes require careful evaluation of the specific circumstances.

Can a surrogacy agreement be challenged in Florida?

Florida law contains specific requirements governing gestational surrogacy arrangements. Disputes may arise concerning the interpretation, validity, or enforcement of an agreement. The legal options available depend on the terms of the agreement and the circumstances involved.

Can an ART dispute involve parties in different states or countries?

Yes. Assisted reproductive arrangements may involve intended parents, gestational carriers, donors, or fertility providers located in different jurisdictions. These circumstances can raise complicated questions involving jurisdiction, parental rights, and recognition of court orders.

When should I contact an IVF or ART litigation attorney?

If you believe a fertility clinic made an error involving your embryos, sperm, eggs, or reproductive treatment, or if you are involved in a dispute concerning surrogacy, parentage, or reproductive agreements, obtaining legal advice promptly can help you understand your rights and preserve potential legal options.

Contact a Florida IVF & ART Litigation Attorney

When assisted reproduction does not go as planned, the legal consequences can be overwhelming.

Whether you are dealing with an IVF embryo mix-up, a fertility clinic error, lost or destroyed embryos, a contested surrogacy agreement, or a dispute involving parental rights, Tate Healey Webster can help you understand the legal issues and evaluate your options.

Our attorneys provide experienced, thoughtful representation in complex assisted reproductive technology matters throughout Florida.

Contact Tate Healey Webster to schedule a confidential consultation regarding your ART litigation matter.

Banner media
Map media
Map background media
Contact us media Contact us media Contact us media

Speak With Us Today

Your Trusted Partner in the Adoption & Surrogacy Process

With years of experience and a commitment to personalized service, Tate Healey Webster Adoption Attorneys is proud to be a trusted partner in adoption throughout the state. We understand that every adoption is unique, which is why we offer tailored legal solutions and support. If you’re ready to begin your adoption journey, contact us today. Let us help you bring your family closer together through the miracle of adoption.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
Submit Information

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy(opens in a new tab) and Terms of Service(opens in a new tab) apply.

Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at (813) 258-3355.
Contact Us